top of page
Search

No-Cry Sleep Training Explained: Why Connection Works Better Than Control

As an Infant and Child Sleep Consultant, one of the most common questions I receive is: “Do you use sleep training?” The short answer is: no, I don’t. But why? The explanation behind this choice is layered, evidence-informed, and rooted in years of experience with thousands of families. The decision not to use traditional sleep training methods is not based on a lack of effectiveness in changing behaviour. It’s based on a commitment to understanding the why behind sleep difficulties, and prioritising the emotional well-being, biology, and communication of the child.


Sleep training, at its core, is designed to modify a child’s external behaviour rather than understand and support the underlying cause of the sleep disturbance. While sleep training may result in a child falling asleep without crying after several nights, this doesn't necessarily mean the child has learned to sleep better. More often, it means the child has learned not to signal for support, not that their sleep has improved in quality. Suppressing communication should never be the measure of success.


My work is grounded in respecting the child’s biology, emotions, nervous system, and communication, none of which align with behavioural sleep training. Sleep is a biological function, not a learned or taught behaviour. Just as we don’t train our babies to breathe, digest, or grow, we don’t need to train them to sleep.


Sleep is hardwired into the human body, governed by intricate rhythms and regulated by the brain and nervous system. So when a child struggles to fall or stay asleep, it’s not a sign that they need to be taught or trained; it’s a red flag that something in their biology, physiology, or emotional state is making it difficult for sleep to occur naturally.


This is where my approach comes in: instead of using traditional sleep training methods like controlled crying, extinction, spaced soothing or timed intervals, I use responsive, connection-based strategies that nurture the relationship between parent and child, while gently supporting better sleep.



child crying at bedtime

So, What’s Wrong With Traditional Sleep Training?


One of the biggest myths perpetuated by mainstream sleep training is that sleep is a skill children must learn. But sleep is not a skill that needs to be taught; it is a physiological necessity. It’s a vital biological function, just like breathing or digesting food; our bodies are designed to sleep. When a child is unable to fall asleep or stay asleep, this doesn’t mean they haven’t learned how to sleep; it means something is interrupting their body's natural sleep rhythm. That interference can be physiological, medical, nutritional, anatomical, biological in nature, or a regulatory issue (find out more on underlying issues impacting sleep).


Just as we wouldn’t train a baby to breathe, we don’t need to train them to sleep. We need to nurture it. Sleep should come naturally, and when it doesn’t, the goal should be to uncover why, not suppress the expression of distress. Behavioural methods like cry-it-out or controlled crying disregard that philosophy. They’re based on the idea that sleep is a behaviour to fix, not a symptom to investigate. Our job isn’t to teach them to sleep, it’s to support them and facilitate their opportunity to sleep, by removing the obstacles and responding with safety, presence, and trust.


Sleep training methods often focus on reducing or eliminating a child’s need for parental support during sleep, and they do this by teaching a child to stop signalling (crying, calling out, resisting). While these methods might result in longer stretches of sleep, they often come at a cost to the child’s emotional security and the parent’s instincts.


Here’s what concerns me most:


  • Sleep training always ignores the root cause of sleep difficulties. Many children struggle with underlying issues so coercing a child to sleep by ignoring their cues doesn’t resolve the problem; it masks it.

  • It can rupture trust and connection. Babies and toddlers cry because they are trying to communicate, not manipulate. When a child is left alone to cry, their nervous system shifts into stress mode. While some eventually stop crying, it's often not because they’ve learned to self-soothe, but because they’ve stopped expecting help. Self-soothing is a highly misunderstood term. Find out more about self-soothing in my blog: Self-Settling vs Self-Soothing vs Resettling

  • It dismisses the parent-child relationship. Sleep is a vulnerable state. A child needs to feel deeply safe, physically and emotionally, in order to relax into sleep. Connection is the foundation of sleep, not an obstacle to it.



Why I Don’t Offer Cookie-Cutter Sleep Solutions


If you’re seeking genuine improvement in your child’s sleep, you might be surprised to learn that it’s not as simple as applying age-based sleep training strategies. Many modern sleep consultants still rely on generalised frameworks or rigid age-by-age methods, but sleep is far too nuanced for that. I don’t use sleep training or cookie-cutter sleep methods because sleep is varied, and no two children are the same. This means, I don't provide generic, age appropriate methods in open forums; it's not a good code of practice for any sleep consultant to offer that.


Sleep is a complex, deeply individual experience that reflects the interplay of multiple systems; emotional, physiological, environmental, and relational. A child’s ability to fall and stay asleep is influenced by so much more than age or a checklist of “typical” behaviours. That’s why my approach is always holistic and personalised, grounded in the understanding that each child and family brings their own unique context to the table.


A truly effective sleep plan considers the entire sleep ecosystem, including:


  • The parenting style and values of the caregivers

  • The emotional capacity, boundaries, and triggers of the parents

  • The child’s sleep history and any known or unknown underlying causes

  • The family’s realistic sleep goals and what balance feels sustainable

  • The child’s temperament, sensory profile, and emotional response to change

  • The quality of the sleep environment, including light, sound, and stimulation levels

  • The circadian rhythm and whether the child’s sleep-wake cycle is in sync

  • Any contributing medical, nutritional, or developmental factors


When we reduce sleep support to just changing a child’s behaviour, like falling asleep alone or sleeping through the night, we miss a huge part of the picture. Sleep behaviour is just the tip of the iceberg. If we don’t understand and address the underlying factors impacting sleep, we may see short-term improvement, but the core struggles will remain unresolved.


This is why I work with families, not on the child. I treat each case as a full, interconnected system, respecting both the science of sleep and the emotional experience of the child and parent. The strategies I suggest are tailored, responsive, and personalised.


Generic advice often fails because it ignores what matters most: context. The same plan can’t possibly suit a sensitive toddler who thrives on co-regulation, and an energetic child who benefits from structure and high movement input. Nor can we expect the same approach to work for a parent who is triggered by their child's emotional response, as we would for a parent who is emotionally regulated, regardless of their child's emotional output. Each situation is different and each family deserves a strategy that reflects that.


When we try to apply standardised sleep plans to real families with real emotions, histories, and complexities, we’re not only setting families up for frustration, we may even cause harm. Behavioural-based approaches focus solely on the external presentation (e.g. frequent night waking or bedtime resistance, for example), but without digging into the why, we never actually solve the problem. And if the root cause is something like nutritional deficiencies, mouth breathing, chronic overstimulation, or unrecognised emotional needs, then ignoring those factors won’t help; you can't "out-sleep train" a nutritional deficiency, for example. In fact, it may even worsen the problem.


Behavioural techniques, on their own, are not enough. They are one small tool in a much larger toolkit, and one that should only ever be used with care, compassion, and individualisation, if at all. That is why I don't offer generic methods for you to apply at your own pace.


mum holding her baby while its crying

Understanding the Emotional Response to Change


When parents begin to shift their child’s sleep expectations, whether it's moving away from feeding to sleep, ceasing co-sleeping or changing the bedtime settle, it’s common for children to have an emotional response. This reaction is not defiance, manipulation, or “bad habits.” It is the nervous system’s natural way of reacting to change. A child’s protest is an expression of uncertainty, a way of saying, “Something feels different—am I still safe?” The goal in these moments isn’t to silence that response, but to support it, validate it, and help the child move through the transition with security and trust intact.


Children rely heavily on predictability, consistency, and proximity to feel emotionally safe. Their sense of security is rooted in knowing how and when their caregivers will respond. When we alter the way we support them around sleep, even if the changes are gentle and necessary, we must be equally mindful of how their emotional needs are still being met. If we overlook that part of the equation, change can feel like abandonment rather than progress.


This is why I don’t rely on rigid and generic sleep training techniques that attempt to condition children out of expressing their needs. Instead, I work with families in a way that honours the child’s emotional experience while helping parents implement meaningful, sustainable changes.


I offer tailored advice based on the unique information parents share with me; details about their child’s behaviours, rhythms, sensitivities, and reactions. By closely listening to how the child is communicating, both verbally and non-verbally, I can better understand what their emotional output is truly telling us. This insight helps me determine what kind of support the individual child actually needs, and how to adjust sleep expectations without overwhelming their developing nervous system.


Generic and traditional sleep methods simply don’t allow for this level of emotional attunement.


You can read more about the emotional response to change in my blog: Breaking Sleep Associations Gently


What “No Cry Sleep Training” Really Means: Responsive Sleep Support Without Leaving Your Child to Cry Alone


Babies and children rely on co-regulation to feel safe enough to sleep. When their caregiver responds consistently, compassionately, and calmly, it builds security, emotional resilience, and eventually, independent sleep.


My strategies aren't about avoiding all tears; "no cry sleep training" is near impossible based on the purpose of crying and the psychology behind change however, it’s about not leaving a child alone in those tears. Crying is a communication tool, and when we remain present and attuned, we can support their emotional needs without reinforcing sleep associations that may no longer serve them.


My philosophy is rooted in respect for both the child’s biology and the parent’s intuition. I believe in working with families, not against them. Here’s how I do that:


1. Identifying the Root Cause

When a child has a sleep presentation that falls beyond the realm of biologically normal sleep patterns, such as waking frequently, taking hours to fall asleep, or needing constant support to stay asleep, I don’t jump to fix the behaviour, I investigate what’s underneath it. This might involve assessing feeding patterns, emotional stressors, oral and airway development, nap routines, nutrition, overstimulation, or something else. Sleep struggles don’t happen in isolation; they’re usually a symptom of something deeper.


2. Nervous System and Emotional Support

A dysregulated nervous system cannot sleep well. I support families in helping their child feel emotionally secure, using co-regulation techniques, responsive bedtime strategies, and consistent rhythms. I teach parents how to be a calming presence and help their child feel safe, even in moments of protest or transition.


3. Honouring the Parent-Child Bond

Instead of pulling parents away from their child in the name of “independence,” I support responsive sleep methods that gradually shift patterns with connection intact. I help parents wean off certain sleep associations if they choose to, but only with compassion, consent, and gentleness. There’s no rush, no “training,” no crying it out.


4. Building Sleep Confidence

My goal is never to “fix” a child. My goal is to help parents understand what their child is communicating through their sleep, and then empower them with tools and strategies to respond effectively. I want parents to feel confident, not conflicted.



A Gentle Approach That Works


Gentle sleep support isn’t about letting your child stay dependent forever. It’s about walking them through the process of sleep in a way that’s respectful, biologically aligned, and emotionally safe.


When children feel safe, connected, and understood, they sleep better.


When parents feel informed, supported, and empowered, they respond better.


That’s what I offer: a way forward that doesn’t compromise your values or your child’s emotional well-being. No cry-it-out. No harsh methods. Just real sleep solutions, rooted in understanding and connection, and guided by science.


Sleep is never just about sleep. It’s about regulation, nutrition, movement, connection, environment, health, sensory input, and so much more. That’s why my approach is holistic; it considers every angle of your child’s development and your family’s situation. I might explore things like breathing patterns, mouth posture, iron levels, oral restrictions, the sleep environment, emotional attachment, and more. These are all pieces of the puzzle, and when they come together, sleep becomes easier, because the body and nervous system are finally supported to do what they’re biologically wired to do.



a mum holding her baby in the nursery

Parents Are Not Selfish for Wanting Sleep to Improve


Gentle, responsive sleep support offers an alternative path; one where change can still happen, but with empathy and safety at its core. Yes, change can be hard. It might involve moments of protest or resistance. But it doesn’t have to involve leaving your child to cry alone or overriding your instincts. You don’t have to go to extreme measures to make progress. But some form of change is often needed, because the alternative is continuing to live in survival mode. And that’s not sustainable.


If nothing changes, nothing changes. Ongoing sleep deprivation can take a serious toll, not just on your mental and physical health, but on your relationships, your capacity for joy, your parenting, and your sense of self. You don’t need to hit burnout before it becomes “bad enough” to do something about it.


And as an important reminder: it is not selfish to want more sleep. You are human too. You have needs, emotions, and limits. You are not “just a mum” or “just a dad.” You’re a whole person and your wellbeing matters just as much as your child’s. Sleep deprivation isn’t a rite of passage. It’s a serious health concern that can impact your ability to function, connect, and thrive.


One of the most common things I hear from parents is: “I just want to feel like myself again.” And I want that for you too.


This is where my work begins, with honouring both your child’s developmental needs and your right to rest, think clearly, and feel present in your life. You don’t have to choose between sleep and connection. You don’t have to sacrifice your child’s emotional safety to get more rest. And you don’t have to rely on rigid, outdated methods that go against your parenting instincts to see real progress.


There is a better way that respects your values, supports your child’s emotional needs, and is grounded in the science of sleep. My responsive, connection-based approach honours your instincts and walks alongside you, not above you, as we uncover the root of your child’s sleep challenges and move together toward gentle, lasting resolution.


If sleep isn’t happening, there’s always a reason. And we’ll find it, together.


Do you want to know more about how responsive sleep support could work for your family?


Book a free discovery call or explore my gentle sleep support services:



I would love to be the missing and final piece on your journey towards improving your child's sleep.


Reach out today to get started on your sleep journey.


Shereen Nielsen

Gentle Sleep Coach


I'm Shereen Nielsen, a certified Sleep Consultant specialising in infants and children from birth to 15 years old. With over 9 years of experience, I've assisted over 4500 families in achieving better sleep. Additionally, I serve as a lecturer and mentor, guiding aspiring sleep consultants on their path to certification through my internationally recognised online Sleep Consultant Course.


Phone: +61419820474



 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page